A common question jewelry shoppers ask me is, “What type of earring back is best?” Like most things in jewelry, the answer depends on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and the type of earrings you’re wearing. Understanding the differences between various types of earring backs can help you make a more informed decision.
From push backs to screw backs, and guardian (La Pousette) backs to ball backings, each has its own unique advantages and ideal use cases. Let’s dive into the details of these popular options to help you decide which one suits you best.
What are earring backs?
Earring backs are small components that secure earrings in place, preventing them from slipping off. While they may seem like a minor detail, the right earring back can significantly impact your comfort, ease of use, and peace of mind and sometimes even the way an earring seats on your ear.
Push Backs
Push backs, also known as friction backs, are the most common type of earring back. These consist of a small, butterfly-shaped metal piece that slides onto the earring post and holds it in place with friction.
Pros:
- Easy to use: They are simple to put on and take off.
- Versatile: Suitable for most types of earrings, from studs to drop earrings.
- Affordable: Typically included with most earrings.
Cons:
- Security: They may not be as secure as other types, making them less ideal for valuable earrings.
- Wear over time: The friction mechanism can loosen, requiring occasional replacement.
Screw Backs
Screw backs provide a more secure option, featuring a threaded post and a backing that screws onto it. These are commonly used for high-value earrings, such as diamond studs.
Pros:
- Highly secure: Once screwed in, they are unlikely to come off accidentally.
- Ideal for valuable jewelry: Provides peace of mind for expensive pieces.
Cons:
- Time-consuming: Screwing the back on and off can be tedious.
- Small parts: The backs are small and can be tricky to handle, especially for individuals with limited dexterity.
Guardian (La Pousette) Backs
Guardian backs, also known as La Pousette backs, are a premium choice that combines security and ease of use. These backs feature a locking mechanism that snaps into place on a specially designed earring post.
Pros:
- Exceptional security: The locking mechanism ensures the earring stays firmly in place.
- Ease of use: Despite their secure design, they are easy to attach and remove.
- Comfort: They are designed to sit flush against the earlobe.
Cons:
- Cost: Typically more expensive than push backs or screw backs.
- Limited availability: Often found only on high-end earrings.
Ball Backings
Ball backings are a less common but stylish option. These consist of a spherical metal piece that attaches to the post and is often favored for its aesthetic appeal.
Pros:
- Aesthetic: The ball design adds a decorative element to the earring’s back.
- Comfort: The rounded shape prevents irritation and pressure on the earlobe.
- Versatility: Can be used for both pierced earrings and some clip-on styles.
Cons:
- Security: May not be as secure as screw or guardian backs.
- Less common: Not widely available, limiting your choices.
Comparing Comfort and Security (Chart)
| Type | Comfort | Security | Ease of Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Push Backs | High | Moderate | High |
| Screw Backs | Moderate | High | Low |
| Guardian Backs | High | Very High | High |
| Ball Backings | Very High | Low | Moderate |
Maintenance and Longevity
- Push Backs: Require occasional replacement due to wear.
- Screw Backs: Durable but require careful handling to avoid damaging threads.
- Guardian Backs: Long-lasting with minimal maintenance.
- Ball Backings: Durable but may require periodic cleaning to maintain their aesthetic.
Best Earring Back for Sensitive Ears
For those with sensitive ears, guardian backs and ball backings are excellent options. Their designs minimize pressure on the earlobe and are often made from hypoallergenic materials like platinum or surgical-grade stainless steel.
Style and Aesthetic Impact
Each earring back has a distinct visual impact. Ball backings, for example, add a decorative touch to the back of the earring, making them ideal for hairstyles that expose the earlobes. Push and screw backs are more discreet, allowing the focus to remain on the earring itself.
Size of the Earring and Backing
The size of the earring and its backing should complement each other for both functionality and aesthetics:
- Small Earrings: Lightweight studs or small drops pair well with push backs or screw backs. Ensure the backing isn’t too large, as it could overwhelm the earring or feel uncomfortable.
- Large Earrings: Heavier or statement stud earrings benefit from large guardian backs or oversized push backs, which provide better support and prevent sagging. I personally recommend 8mm+ push backing and guardian backings to clients who purchase stud earrings that are larger that 2carat each stone. Larger backings are the best way to prevent sagging on the ear do to the weight of the stone.
- Balance: Always check that the backing’s size is proportional to the earring’s weight and design. This ensures the earring stays secure and looks balanced when worn.
- Specialized Backs: Ball backings are ideal for larger earrings with a decorative intent, adding visual interest while maintaining comfort.
This chart is minimum size backing recommendation based on years of advising clients. Typically going with larger backing than the minimum recommended is best.
Which earring back is right for you?
Consider the following factors when choosing an earring back:
- Lifestyle: If you lead an active lifestyle, prioritize security with screw or guardian backs.
- Comfort: For all-day wear, ball backings and guardian backs are highly comfortable.
- Budget: Push backs are the most affordable, while guardian backs are a premium choice.
- Aesthetics: Choose ball backings if you want a decorative element visible from behind.
Conclusion
Earring backs may be small, but they play a big role in your jewelry’s wearability and security. Whether you prioritize comfort, security, or style, there’s an earring back to suit your needs. Push backs are great for everyday earrings, while screw backs and guardian backs offer enhanced security for valuable pieces. Ball backings provide a unique combination of comfort and style.
Explore our earring collection
Browse our range of diamond earrings and diamond stud earrings, complete with your choice of earring backs. From push backs to guardian backs, we’ve got something for everyone.
In addition to offering all the classic earring options, we specialize in custom designed earrings, including stud earrings tailored to your desired size, metal, and style. Our customer service team is always ready to assist you in creating the perfect pair.
